Formlearning,whichisshowninFigure5,wasfairlygoodoverall,withfalsealarmstofoilsrangingaround10%.Nevertheless,skilledcomprehendersweremoreaccurateatrejectingsimilarfoilsandselectingthecorrectform.Afteroneses-sionoflearning,lessskilledcomprehenderschoseafoilon20%oftrials.Figure5doesnotdistinguishamongfoiltypes,butthereweredifferences:Thefoilswithhighphonemicoverlapattractedthehighestpercentageoffalsealarms,andfoilswithlessphonemicoverlapbuthighorthographicoverlapwerenext.Controlfoils,whichsharedonlytheinitialletterwiththetarget,attractedfewfalsealarms.However,therewasnointeractionofthetypeoffoilwithreadergroup.Bothskilledandlessskilledcomprehendersmademoreerrorstofoilswhenbothorthographicandphone-micoverlapwashigh.Thus,theconclusionisthatskilledcomprehenderslearnnotonlynewwordmeaningsmoreeffectivelybutalsonewformsmoreeffectively.LQimpliescoherencebetweenformandmeaningcomponents,andskillinreadingisas-sociatedwithhigherLQrightfromthebeginningoflearning.
Theideaofstabilityismorespecificthaneffectiveformlearning.Itimpliesthattheword’srepresentationcomestocomprisespellingandpronunciationpatternsthatareidenticalonsuccessiveobservations.OnewaytoexaminestabilityinthisFIGURE5Formaccuracy(lexicaldecisions)overfourmeaninglearningsessions.Hitratesforrealrarewords(e.g.,hebetude)comparedwithfalsealarmstosimilarforms(hebitude,hebetade, etc.). Less skilled comprehenders show less word-form accuracy.
372
PERFETTI
senseisshowninFigure6,whichplotsperformanceonsuccessivelexicalchoicetrials.Theperformanceplottedisconditionalforsessionsbeyondthefirst:Givenacorrectchoiceinonetestsession,theprobabilityofbeingcorrectthenexttime.Thuschoosinghebetudeatonetestbutthenhebitudeonthenextwouldcontributenegativelytothismeasure,whichisoneofstability—choosingthesameformthenexttime.Figure6showsagaintheslightlybetterperformanceofskilledcompre-hendersrightfromthebeginning,thatis,fromthefirstsession.Stability(condi-tionalprobabilitiesofcorrectresponses)showsasmallbutconsistentdifferenceonthenexttwosessions,andthedifferencebecomeslargestonthefinalsession,whenskilledcomprehendersproduced96%stabilitycomparedwith86%forlessskilled comprehenders.
Aninformalcharacterizationofthisresultisthatthelessskilledgroup,onaver-age,showsasmallbutnoticeableinstabilityevenafterfoursessionsoflearning.This is evidence in favor of the stability implication of LQ.
Less Skilled Comprehenders’Semantic Processing
of Ordinary Words
Thetwoprecedingsectionshaveconcludedthatproblemsinlearningwordmean-ingsandinlearningwordformsbothassociatewithcomprehensionskill.IntheFIGURE6Anindicatorofformstabilityduringwordlearning.Theconditionalprobabilityofacorrectdecisiononrarewordsgivenacorrectresponseontheprecedingtrialoversucces-sivelexicaldecisionsessions.Lessskilledcomprehendersshowslightlylesswordformstabil-ity by this measure.
LEXICAL QUALITY373
StudiesofForm–MeaningConfusionssection,weconcludedthatproblemsinmeaningprocessesthatwereassociatedwithformweremorelikelyforlessskilledreaders.Inthissectionweconsidersemanticprocessingdifferencesforordinarywords already known to the reader.
Thehypothesisthatsemanticdeficitsmayexplaincomprehensionproblemshasbeendevelopedandtestedforchildren(Nation&Snowling,1998,1999)ndi(2005;Landi&Perfetti,2007)extendedtherangeofthishypothesistoincludeadults,linkingbehavioralandERPmeasurestotheassessmentsofspecificlexicalandcomprehensionskill.Ineffect,Landi’sexperimentstargetedthegroupofread-ersofFigure1whoareinthelowerrightquadrant—belowthediagonalandtotherightofthex-axismidpoint:readersofhighlexicalskillbutlowcomprehensionskill.
Landitestedthehypothesisthatsuchreadersarelessabletoeffectivelyusese-manticcategoryinformation.Participantsmademeaningdecisionsforwordpairsthatwererelatedassociativelyandcategoricallyorcategoricallyonly.Forexam-ple,brother–sister,dog–cat,pillow–sleepwerepairsbothassociativelyandcate-goricallyrelated;green–pink,banana–tomato,kite–ndi’shypothesiswasbasedonNationandSnowling’s(1999)conclusionthatchildren’scomprehensionproblemsreflectedfailurestorepresentsemanticcategoryrelations.Thus,lessskilledcomprehenderswouldbecompara-bletoskilledcomprehendersinsemanticprocesseswhenassociativerelationscouldfacilitatedetectionofsemanticrelations,buttheywouldbelesssuccessfulthanskilledcomprehenderswhentheyhadtorelyonlyoncategoricalrelations.Toprovidemoreinformativecomparisons,participantsalsomadesemanticjudg-mentsonpairsofpictures(controllingforwordreading)andhomophonedeci-sions,forexample,boar–bore,chants–chance,tacks–tax(assessingphonologicalprocessing).
Thekeyresultscanbesummarizedasfollows:Accuracywasgenerallyhighforalltasksandnotdifferentbetweenthetwogroups.However,timesforcorrectdeci-sionswerefasterfortheskilledgroupthanthelessskilledgroupacrossalltasks.Thus,skilledcomprehendersshowedfastersemanticprocessingwhetherthestim-uliwerewordsorpicturesandfasterwordjudgmentswhetherthedecisionwasbasedonmeaningorpronunciation.Forwordmeanings,thedecisiontimestosemanticcategorypairswereslowerthantoassociativepairs.Thisconfirmstheas-sumptionthatdetectingcategoryrelationswouldrequiremoreprocessingthande-tectingrelationsbetweenassociations.Correctdecisionsbasedoncategoryrela-tionstookanaverageof68mseclongerthanthosebasedonassociativerelationsfortheskilledgroupand139mseclongerforthelessskilledgroup.Thesegroupdifferences,althoughinthedirectionimpliedbyLandi’sextensionofNationandSnowling’s (1999) hypothesis, were not reliable.
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说医药卫生Reading Ability- Lexical Quality to Comprehension(7)在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: