WORD PROCESSING, WORD LEARNING,
AND COMPREHENSION STUDIES
WiththisbackgroundonthegeneralnatureoftheLQhypothesis(LQH)anditslinkstotheprocess-orientedaccountofverbalefficiency,IturnnowtoareviewofsomestudiesofreadingthatbearontheLQH.Althoughthesearestudiesofadultreading, I believe their conclusions apply also to children’s reading.
TheStructureofLexicalandComprehensionSkillinReading
Lexicalknowledgeandcomprehensionshouldbeassociated,andtheyare.Posi-tivecorrelationsbetweenword-processingmeasuresofvariouskindsandreadingcomprehensionassessmentsarewellestablishedinbothchildren(Perfetti,1985)andadults(Haenggi&Perfetti,1994).Moreinterestingisthefactthatthiscorrela-tionisgenerallyinthemoderaterange,leavingplentyofroomfordisassociationbetweenthetwo.We’vemaintainedalargedatabaseofcollegestudentsforwhomwetakevariousreadingandreading-relatedmeasures.Ingeneral,weareinter-estedinknowingtheassociatesofreadingcomprehensionskillandintheout-comesofexperimentsthatrelatedspecificreadingprocessestothesemeasures.PerfettiandHart(2002)reportedsomeresultsoffactoranalysisonasampleof445individualsfromthisdatabase.Theyconcludedthatskilledreaders’knowledgeofspelling,phonology,anddecodingcouldberepresentedreasonablywellbyasin-glewordformfactorwithasecondfactorreflectingmeaningandcomprehension.However,lessskilledreaders,inadditiontoameaningfactor,requiredtwoform
362PERFETTI
factors—oneloadedwithmorephonologicaltasksandtheotherwithmoreortho-graphic tasks, suggesting less coherence of word identities.
Sincethentwodissertationshaveassessedlargesamplesfromthisdatabase,basedonpartlydifferenttasks,onebyHart(2005)andalateronebyLandi(2005).BothHartandLandiwereinterestedinthedisassociationofword-levelskillfromcomprehensionskill,asassessedbytheNelson–Dennycomprehen-siontest.Hartanalyzedthescoresof792students,concludingthat,amongthosewhocouldbemostconfidentlyclassified,18%werebelowthemedianincom-prehensionbutatorabovethemedianonlexicalmeasures;64%showedthemoretypicalassociationpatternoflexicalandcomprehensionscoresbothhighorbothlow.Inherexperimentswithacarefullydefinedsubsetofthissample,Hartaskedwhethercertainaspectsoflearninganartificiallanguagemightde-pendmoreonfirst-languagelexicalknowledgecomparedwithfirst-languagecomprehensionskill.Herresultsshowedacomplexpattern,withbothcompre-hensionandlexicalknowledgepredictingvariousmeasuresofperformancewiththenovellanguageduringlearningandinpostlearningtransfer.However,lexicalknowledge,morethancomprehension,predictedthelearningofthisartificiallanguage,includingitsnovelorthographyanditsdecodingmappings.Italsopredictedresistancefrominterferencebyhomophonesthatwereplantedinthenewlanguage,replicatingaresultreportedinPerfettiandHart(2001)forEng-lish.
Landi’ndi’sfactoranalysisoffivetasksyieldedacomprehensioncomponentandalexicalcomponent,whichshethenusedtoweightnormalizeindividualparticipantscoresoneachtest.Figure1showsascatterplotofthesescores.Inthisnormalizedanalysis,23%werebelowthemedianonthecomprehensioncomponentbutabovethemedianonthelexicalcomponent;thereversepattern,highcomprehensionbutlowlexicalcomponents,wasobservedfor9%ofthesample.Thisasymmetryisthepatternonewouldex-pect(butmightnotfindbasedonmediansplitsoftestscores).Lexicalknowledgeisnotsufficientforcomprehension,sothelow-comprehension/highlexicalpatternismoreprominentthanthehigh-comprehension/low-lexicalpattern.Theapproxi-mately20%(18%inHart’ssample,23%inLandi’ssample)ofcollegestudentswhosecomprehensionlevelsundershootthelevelexpectedbylexicalskillsidenti-fiesagroupforwhomhypothesesaboutothersourcesofcomprehensionproblemscan be meaningfully tested.
Theideathatlexicalprocessesarenotsufficientforcomprehensionshouldnotbecontroversial,althoughacarelessreadingofverbalefficiencytheorymighthaveledsometobelievethatthetheoryassumedtherewasnothingtocomprehen-sionbeyondefficientwordreading.Observationstothecontraryhavelongbeenintheliterature,andatleastafewofthemseemtohavecontrolledadequatelyforword-levelskills.StudiesbyOakhillandcolleagues(Cain&Oakhill,1999;
LEXICAL QUALITY
363
FIGURE1Scatterplotofnormalizedcomponentscoresfromprincipalcomponentsanalysisofreadingtestscoresfromasampleof799collegestudents,basedonLandi’s(2005)disserta-tion.Inthisprocedure,normalizedZscoresforeachtestforeachparticipantweremultipliedbythefactorscoreforthattestdeterminedfromthePrincipleComponentsAnalysis.Thus,theplotisafactor-weightedcompositeoffivetests(decoding,spelling,vocabulary,comprehension,and the Author Recognition Test) that weighted differentially on the two components.
Oakhill,Cain,&Bryant,2003)seemtoshowthatsomechildrenhavetroubledrawinginferencesduringcomprehension,despitehavinggooddecodingskills.Moregenerally,comprehensionproblemscanarisefromgenerallanguagecom-prehensionproblemsevenwhenworddecodingappearstobeadequate(Stodhard&Hulme,1996).(Forreviews,seeNation,2006,andPerfetti,Landi,&Oakhill,2005).Anothercandidateforcomprehensionproblems,closertotheideaofLQ,isthehypothesisthatchildrenwithadequatedecodingandphonological-levelskillscanhaveword-levelsemanticproblemsthataffectcomprehension.Thissemanticdeficithypothesis(Nation&Snowling,1998,1999),whichhassomeevidenceinstudiesofchildren,allowsforseveralinterpretationsofsemanticdeficits,includ-ingaproblemwithsemanticcategories.Fornow,theLandiandHartstudiesex-tendtotheadultpopulationtheobservationthatdecodingisnotsufficientforcom-prehension.
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说医药卫生Reading Ability- Lexical Quality to Comprehension(3)在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: