Studies of Form–Meaning Confusions
OnewaytostudytheeffectsofLQoncomprehensionistoexperimentallycreatethreatstoquality.ThisisthebasisforexperimentsreportedinPerfettiandHart(2001),whichIonlybrieflyreviewhere.Thekeyideaisthatforawordlikewails,
364PERFETTI
thequalityofitsidentity,whichentailsitsspelling,pronunciation,andmeaning,isthreatenedbytheexistenceofwhales,whichsharesitspronunciation.Sohowdoreadersofhigherandlevelskillhandlethiskindofthreat?Ourhypothesiswasthatbetterreaders,definedbycomprehensionassessment,havehigherqualityrepre-sentations,sogivenwail,theyshouldretrievewailassociates,notwhaleassoci-ates,evenifthereismomentaryactivationofboththepresentedwordanditsho-mophone (Gernsbacher & Faust, 1991).
InthemeaningtaskreportedinPerfettiandHart(2001),readersdecidedwhethertwowordspresentedinsuccessionweresemanticallyrelated.Sometrialscontainedhomophonesofwordsthatwouldhavebeenrelated,aswhenwailswasfollowedbydolphins.Skilledcomprehendersshowedfaster-meaningdecisionsforbothcontrolpairsandhomophones,andtheyshowedlesshomophoneconfu-sionwhenthepresented(confusable)formwastheoneofhigherfrequency(whales–criesratherthanwails–dolphins).However,theydidshowconfusionswhenpresentedwithaformoflowfrequency,andthiseffectoccurredatshorterla-tenciesthanitdidforlessskilledcomprehenders.Sonight–armordidnotproduceconfusion(intheformoflongerdecisiontimes)forskilledcomprehenders,al-thoughitdidforlessskilledcomprehenders.However,knight–eveningproducedinterferenceforskilledcomprehenders,andthisemergedveryrapidly,ataStimu-lusOnsetAsynchronyof150msec,whereasforlessskilledcomprehendersthein-terferenceeffectdidnotemergeuntil450msec.Thus,skilledcomprehendersshowlessinterferencebasedonform,andwhentheyshowinterference,itoccurswithin150msofexposuretothehomophone,suggestinganearlyactivationofword phonology.
Thisfrequencyeffectinhomophoneconfusionsappearstobedependentonwordexperience.InastudyreportedinHartandPerfetti(inpress),readerswereprovidedwithexperienceonthememberofahomophonepairthatwasjudgedtobelessfamiliar,soastomakeitmorefamiliarthanitsmate.Forexample,inthepairnight–knight,knightwasratedlowerinfamiliarity,soitwastheonepartici-pantsexperiencedintraining;similarly,inhair–hare,harewasratedlower,soitwasthetrainingword.Theresultofthetraining,whichconsistedofvisualexpo-surestothewordassociatedwithmeaning,wasthereversalofthefrequencyeffectinhomophoneinterference.Intermsoftheexamples,trainingonknightcausedse-manticdecisionsonknight–eveningtoproducelessinterferencethansemanticde-cisionsonnight–armor.Soform-basedconfusionsdependontherelativefrequen-ciesofcompetingforms,whichinturndependonreadingexperience.Ahighlyfrequentformisrelativelyprotectedfrominterference,becauseitretrievesitsmeaningandpronunciationrapidlyasastable,uniquewordidentity.Aninfrequentformislessprotectedbecauseitismorelikelytoretrieveanunstableidentitybasedonsharedphonologywiththemorefrequentform.Theapplicationofthistoread-ingskillisthatLQdependsonexperiencewithwords.Askilledcomprehenderhas
LEXICAL QUALITY365
hadmoreexperiencewithagivenwordthanhasalessskilledreader,andthishasimportant implications.1
Therelationshipbetweenwordfrequencyestimatesandvariousword-process-ingtasksisnonlinear,generallylogarithmic.Inlowfrequencyranges,agivendif-ferenceinfrequencybetweentwowordsmayhavealargeeffectonmeasuresofspeedofprocessing;inhighfrequencyranges,thatsamefrequencydifferencehasasmallereffect.Skilldifferencesinword-readingexperimentsareusuallygreaterforlow-frequencywordsthanhigh-frequencywords.Thismayreflecttheimpor-tanceofsomeminimumnumberofexposuresforawordtobeidentifiedwithloweffort.Ifweassumethatagivenwordhasbeenreadmorefrequentlybyaskilledreaderthanalessskilledreader,thenitfollowsthattheskilldifferencesweobserveinprocessingthatwordreflectthisfrequencyofexperiencedifference.However,thedifferenceinexposuresseemstohaveaneffectonlyforlow-frequencywords,consistentwithassumptionthatitisthelow-frequencyrangewhereincrementsinfrequencyaremostimportant.Althoughrecencyeffectscanbedisguisedasfre-quencyeffects,thisdoesnotmatterfortheskillconclusion.Morereadingleads,statistically,tomorefrequentandmorerecentencountersandbothmayhavethisnonlineareffectonword-readingefficiency.Althoughthisstatisticalperspectiveisimportant,itdoesnotmeanthatallexperienceswithwordsareequal.Infact,inthenextsection,Ireviewastudythatsuggeststhatskilledcomprehendersmakebetteruse of their experiences with words they are trying to learn.
Learning the Meanings of New Words
GiventheimplicationthatLQisacquiredthrougheffectiveexperiencewithwords,wemightbeabletoobservetheacquisitionofLQduringwordlearning.Further-more,bycomparingthelearningofreaderswhodifferincomprehensionskill,wecanexaminethelinkbetweenLQandcomprehensioninasituationthatcontrolsthewordexperiences.Inthisresearch,wehaveusedbothbehavioralandERPmeasures.
Perfetti,Wlotko,andHart(2005)taughtthemeaningsofveryrarewordstoun-dergraduatesandthentestedtheeffectsofthislearninginasimplemeaningjudg-menttaskwhilerecordingelectroencephalograms(EEGs).Examplesofthewordstaughtincludethefollowing:gloaming,flexion,clement,ibex,agog,bastion,tiglon,andquisling.Inapretestlexicaldecisiontask,ourrarewordswerejudgedtoberealwordsonlyatarateof8%onaverage.Toassurethatthewordswewould1GernsbacherandFaust(1991;alsoGernsbacher,1990)explainedlessskilledreaders’problemsinmeaningprocessingasduetoproblemsinsuppressingirrelevantmeaningsthatareactivatedbyaword.Differencesbetweentheirmechanism-basedaccountandtheknowledge-basedaccountoftheLQHarediscussed further in Perfetti and Hart (2001).
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说医药卫生Reading Ability- Lexical Quality to Comprehension(4)在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: