SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF READING,11(4),357–383
Copyright ©2007, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Reading Ability: Lexical Quality
to Comprehension
Charles Perfetti
University of Pittsburgh
Thelexicalqualityhypothesis(LQH)claimsthatvariationinthequalityofwordrep-resentationshasconsequencesforreadingskill,includingcomprehension.Highlexi-calqualityincludeswell-specifiedandpartlyredundantrepresentationsofform(or-thographyandphonology)andflexiblerepresentationsofmeaning,allowingforrapidandreliablemeaningretrieval.Low-qualityrepresentationsleadtospecificword-relatedproblemsincomprehension.Sixlinesofresearchonadultreadersdem-onstratesomeoftheimplicationsoftheLQH.First,large-scalecorrelationalresultsshowthegeneralinterdependenceofcomprehensionandlexicalskillwhileidentify-ingdisassociationsthatallowfocusoncomprehension-specificskill.Second,word-levelsemanticprocessingstudiesshowcomprehensionskilldifferencesinthetimecourseofform-meaningconfusions.Studiesofrarevocabularylearningusingevent-relatedpotentials(ERPs)showthat,third,skilledcomprehenderslearnnewwordsmoreeffectivelyandshowstrongerERPindicatorsformemoryofthewordlearningeventand,fourth,suggestskilldifferencesinthestabilityoforthographicrepresentations.Fifth,ERPmarkersshowcomprehensionskilldifferencesinmean-ingprocessingofordinarywords.Finally,intextreading,ERPresultsdemonstratemomentarydifficultiesforlow-skillcomprehendersinintegratingawordwiththepriortext.Thestudiesprovideevidencethatword-levelknowledgehasconsequencesfor word meaning processes in comprehension.
Inreading,thesingularrecurringcognitiveactivityistheidentificationofwords.Fromthisfollowtwoother,relatedobservationsaboutreading:Comprehensiondependsonsuccessfulwordreading.Skilldifferencesincomprehensioncanarisefrom skill differences in word reading.
Thesesimpleobservationsformthecoreofatheoryofcomprehensionskillpublishedover20yearsago(Perfetti,1985).Verbalefficiencytheoryclaimedthat
CorrespondenceshouldbesenttoCharlesPerfetti,LRDC,UniversityofPittsburgh,Pittsburgh,PA15260. E-mail: Perfetti@pitt.edu
358PERFETTI
wordidentification,therapidretrievalofaword’sphonologyandmeaning,wasalimitingfactorincomprehension.Ireferredtothesecognitiveeventsofwordiden-tificationas“retrievals”becausetheyoperatedoninformationaboutawordstoredinareader’sorthographicallyaddressablememory.Butattheheartofwordidenti-ficationwerethephonologicalproceduresthatallowedaword(oranonword)tobedecoded,whetherornotmeaningwasalsoretrieved.Thetheoryassumedtheabilitytodecodenonwordswasthehallmarkofbasicalphabeticreadingskill.Infact,phonologywasimportantenoughinthisaccountthatithadredundantpartici-pation.Phonologywasbothstoredaspartoftheword(andthusretrievedduringidentification)andgeneratedbyconnectionsamongsubwordunitsthatwerepartoftheword.ThisconceptualizationwasexplicitintheRestrictedInteractiveModel,whichfocusedonthedevelopmentwithexperienceofspecificandredun-dant sublexical components suggested in Perfetti (1992).
Inthetheory,thelinkfromword-levelreadingtocomprehensionwasthroughtheassumptionthatcomprehensionincludedhigherlevelprocessesthatrequiredcognitiveresources(workingmemory),forexample,integrativeprocesses,infer-ences,syntacticrepairs.Wordidentification,andcertainlythesublexicalpro-cessesthatproduceit,werecandidatesforlow-resourceorautomaticprocesses(LaBerge&Samuels,1974)thatcouldpreserveprocessingresourcesforhigherlevelcomprehension.Automatic,resource-cheapword-levelprocesses—verbalefficiency—wereassumedtosupportcomprehension.Childrenwhohavethisefficiencywouldbeabletoachievehighlevelsofcomprehension,andchildrenwithinefficientword-levelprocesseswouldhaveproblemswithcomprehension.Theresearchshowingcorrelationsbetweenchildren’sdecodingskillandcom-prehensionwasconsistentwiththisaccount.Furthermore,thereisnoreasontosupposethatthisrelationshipdisappearsforolderreaders(Shankweileretal.,1999).
Thisgeneralaccountcontinuestoseemcorrecttome.However,Ithinkitsem-phasisoncompletelygeneralprocesses—decoding,phonologicalprocesses,re-trieval,memory,automaticity—althoughtheoreticallyconsistent,seemedtoleaveknowledgeoutofthepicture.Skilledreadingwasaboutefficientprocessingmech-anismsandlessskilledreadingwasaboutthesesamemechanismsexecutedineffi-ciently.Thisdescriptionseemedtopredictthatbecomingfasteratwordidentifica-tionleadstobettercomprehension.Inefficientreaderscanindeedbecomemoreefficient(Breznitz&Share,1992),andimprovingindividualwordreadingspeedmayincreasefluency(Martin-Chang&Levy,2005)and,undersomecircum-stances,comprehension(Breznitz&Share,1992;Tan&Nicholson,1997).How-ever,increasingdecodingspeedbyitselfhasnotalwaysincreasedcomprehension(Fleisher,Jenkins,&Pany,1979;Perfetti,1985).Overall,althoughthehypothesisthattrainingword-readingspeedraisescomprehensionhassomeresearchsupport,itisnottheprimarypracticalimplicationofthegeneralideathatcomprehensiondepends on efficient word reading.
LEXICAL QUALITY359
Efficiencyisnotthesameasspeed.Efficiencyisaratioofoutcometoeffort,withtimeasaproxyforeffort.Soalthoughprocessingdescriptionsmakeacoher-entframeworkforefficiency,theyleaveoutthebasicnatureandsourceofthewordreadingoutcomesonwhichefficiencydepends.Theseoutcomesarewordidenti-tiesthatmomentarilyrepresentformandmeaningcomponentsthatarethebasicelementsofcomprehension.Onthisdescription,thethingtounderstandisnotspeedbutrathertheabilitytoretrievewordidentitiesthatprovidethemeaningsthereaderneedsinagivencontext.Thissourceofthisabilityistheknowledgeareaderhas about words, specific lexical representations.
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说医药卫生Reading Ability- Lexical Quality to Comprehension在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: