Onceagain,theERPeffectwasdifferentforskilledandlessskilledcom-prehenders.AlthoughbothgroupsshowedareductionoftheN400whenthesec-ondwordwasrelatedinmeaningtothefirstword,thisN400forlessskilledcomprehenderswassignificantlylessreducedfortrainedwordscomparedwiththereduction for skilled readers.
Wemustconcludethatafterlessthan50minspentlearningthemeaningsof60rarewordswhosemeaningswereunknownpriortothestudy,skilledcom-prehendersmademoreeffectiveuseofthelearningperiod.EspeciallyinterestingisthefactthatthisdifferencewasseeninERPsrecordedduringthebriefperiodinwhichthewordwasbeingviewed,priortotheappearanceofasecondword.TheN400onthesecondwordreflectedthestrongerlearningofthemeaningbyskilledcomprehenders;theepisodicmarkeronthefirstwordindicatedastrongerassocia-tion between the word and its training.
Onemightarguewiththeinterpretationthatthesearelearningeffectsasopposedtosubtleexperienceeffects.Althoughwechosewordsthatwereindividually
LEXICAL QUALITY369
tailoredtobeunknownforagivenparticipant,perhapsthatprocedureunderesti-matedveryslightfamiliaritydifferencesthatfavoredthemoreskilledandmoreex-periencedreaders.Thisseemsunlikely.Foronething,wedidnotfinddifferencesintheuntrainedwords,whichwerefromthesamepopulationofpretestedrarewords.Ifskilledreadershadsomeunmeasuredfamiliaritywiththetrainedwordspriortothestudy,thentheyshouldhavethesameunmeasuredfamiliarityfortheuntrainedwords.ButthebehavioralandERPresultsbothsaytheydidnot.Further-more,theinterpretationthatwehaveadifferenceintheabilitytolearnwordmean-ingsisconsistentwiththeresultsofHart’s(2005)dissertation.Readershighincomprehensionskillshowedbettermeaningdecisionperformancethanlow-skillcomprehenders on words learned in her artificial language.
Acquiring Lexical Form Stability
AsindicatedinTable1,oneofthefeaturesofLQisastablelexicalrepresentation.Stabilityoccursaslettersandphonemeconstituentsbecomespecifiableascon-stants(fullyspecified)ratherthanvariablesinthewordrepresentation.High-qual-ityrepresentationsarefullyspecified(Perfetti,1992).Inastudythatusedrare-wordlearningtoexamineformstabilityduringlearning(Yang&Perfetti,2006),skilledandlessskilledcomprehenderslearnedthemeaningsof42rarewordsoverfourmini–training“sessions”inthecourseofasingleday.Aftereachsession,par-ticipantsalsomadelexicaldecisions,choosingwhetheragivenletterstringwasthecorrectformofawordtheywerelearning.Thefoilsvariedsystematicallyintheirorthographicandphonologicaloverlapwiththecorrectform.Thismanipula-tionallowedtestsofthelearners’formstability.Iflearnersacquirewell-specifiedrepresentationsofthewordtheywerelearning,similarformsshouldproducelessinterference.
Table2illustrateswhatthelearnerswereupagainst.Inthemidstoftryingtolearnthemeaningofthenew,veryrareword,hebetude,learnersencountereitheroneofthespellingsshowninTable2orthecorrectformofthewordhebetude,de-cidingwhetherthepresentedformisthecorrectform.2Orthographicallysimilarfoils(twoleftcolumnsofTable2)hadhighspellingoverlapwiththetarget,andsomeofthesealsohadveryhighphonemicoverlap.Controlfoilssharedonlyaninitialletterwiththetarget.Anunusualfeatureofthisstudyistheuseofmultisyllabicwords,whichrequiredsomeflexibilityincreatingfoils.AsTable2shows,theorthographicfoilsforhebetudeallsharebothgraphemesandphonemesforthefirstofthethreesyllables.(Thismeanssubstantialphonemicoverlapevenamonglowoverlapfoils.)Highphonemicoverlapinthiscasewascarriedby
2AccordingtoWorldWideWords(Quinion,July2007),anAugust2001columninTheWashingtonPostobservedthat“ToomanyAmericansslouchtowardaterminalfunkofhebetudeandsloth.”Itwasalso the “word of the day” on on January 24, 2004.
370PERFETTI
TABLE 2
Foils for the Rare WordHebetude
High Orthographic OverlapHigher PhonologicalOverlap
hebitude
hebatude
hebutude
hebotudeLower PhonologicalOverlaphebetidehebetadehebetedehebetode
Control:First Letter Onlyhodilaneharisadehigiforehudufiseidenticalfirstandthirdsyllables(leftcolumn).Thefourhighoverlapfoilsdifferedonlyonthevowelletterofthesecondunstressedsyllable.Becausethesyllableisunstressed,vowelscanmigratetowardaminimalvowel.Onecouldconceivablypronounce all the second syllable vowels as unstresseduh.
Ofinterestareresultsofbothformandmeaninglearning.Themeaningpartofthestudyinvolvedviewingthewordandhearingaspokendefinition,whichcouldberepeatedatthelearner’soption,followedbyatestofmeaninginwhichthewordwasspoken.Weexplainedtoparticipantsthatlearningthemeaningsofrarewordslikehebetudewasthegoal.Eachofthefoursessionsofmeaninglearningwasfol-lowed by the form task (lexical decision).
ThemeaningresultsareshowninFigure4.Skilledcomprehenderslearnedmorethanlessskilledcomprehendersfromthefirstsession,andtheiradvantageremainedconstantoverthefoursessions.ThisresultconvergeswiththatofFIGURE4Increaseinrarewordlearningoverfourlearning“sessions”(allwithinoneday).Skilledcomprehenderslearnedmoreduringthefirstsessionandmaintainedthisslightadvan-tage.
LEXICAL QUALITY
371
Perfetti,Wlotko,&Hart(2005)infindingthatskilledcomprehenderslearnthemeanings of new words more effectively than less skilled comprehenders.
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说医药卫生Reading Ability- Lexical Quality to Comprehension(6)在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: