In this paper we analyze the requirements access control mechanisms must fulfill in the context of group communication and define a framework for supporting fine-grained access control in client-server group communication systems. Our framework combines ro
operatedbyaPolicyTranslationEnginethatparsesthegrouppolicyandoutputsanother lethattheGCSwilluseinmaking/enforcingaccesscontrol, lethatde nespermissionbasedontherolesandoperationsthattheGCSimplements.Twoadditionaloperationsarerequiredonceapolicyisinplace.The rstoneinvolvesacheckonmakingsurethatthepolicydoesnotincludeanycontradictoryrules.Thesecondonerelateswiththeonethepolicyisdistributedtotheotherserversandmakesurethatallservershavethesamepolicy.Incasethepolicyisstaticallisneededisthatthepolicyiscerti ed(digitallysigned)anddis-tributedbyaserver.Incasethepolicyisdynamic,thepolicy leshouldbetreatedasreplicateddataamongthesetofservers.
Besidesdecisionreaching,anotherimportantaspectiswhoisenforcinganoperation.Formostoftheoperations,theenforcementcanbedonelocallybytheserverthatmakestheauthorizationdecision.Forothergroupoperations,suchasgroupdestroying,theserverenforcingthedecisioncanbedi erentfromtheonemakingthedecision.Forlackofspacewecouldnotincludeadetaileddescriptiononhowenforcementisperformedoneachgroupoperations.Thisinforma-tionisavailablein[19].
4
LifeCycleofanAccessControlPol-icy
Intheprevioussectionwedescribedhowa ne-grainedaccesscontrolpolicyforGCScanbede nedandenforcedinamodelwherefaultsdonothappen.Unfortunately,thisisnotthecaseintherealworldwhereprocessescancrash,computerscanfail,net-workmis-con gurationscanhappen,orthenetworkoverloadcancreateunusuallatenciesthatcanbeper-ceivedasnetworkpartitions.Inthissectionweexam-inehowfailuresandnetworkconnectivitya ectthelifecycleofthepolicy.
Thelifecycleofapolicyisde nedbythepolicycreationandsubsequentupdates.Asdescribedintheprevioussectionweassumethatbasedonanapplica-tionpolicy’sspeci cationsagrouptemplateisgener-ated.ThecreationandrevisionofagrouptemplateishandledbytheadministratorofaGCS.Basedonthetemplate,agrouppolicyiscreatedwhenaclientallowedtocreategroups,createsagroupbasedonthetemplate.
Anaccesscontrolpolicycanbestatic,inotherwordsitcanneverchangeduringthelifeofthegroup,oritcanbedynamic,inwhichcaseitcansu er
changes.Incaseofdynamicpolicies,apolicyrecon-ciliationmustbeperformedinmanycases.Asshownin[16],policyreconciliationcannotalwaysbesolv-able,inwhichcasethequestioniswhathappenstothegroup.Forexample,currentgroupmembersthatdonotsatisfythepolicyanymorecanbeexcludedfromthegroup.Thistaskcanbetakenbythegroupcon-troller.Notethateveninthecaseofstaticpolicies,policyreconciliationcannotbeavoidedwhenseveralgroupsneedtobemerged.
Wenowdiscusswhathappenswhentwoormoregroupsneedtobemerged.Ifthegroupstobemergedhavetheoriginsinthesamegroup–e.g.theyaretheresultofanetworkpartitionthatseparatedagroup–andifthegrouppolicyisstatic,thegroupsshouldinfacthavethesamepolicysonoreconciliationwillbenecessary.Whatneedstobeaddressediswhowillbecomethenewgroupcontroller,sinceeachpolicyspeci esthesamegroupcreatoroftheoriginalgroup,butdi erentcontrollers.
Anothercaseiswhengroupswiththesamenamewerecreatedindependentlyinpartitionedcompo-nents.Somesystemsuniquelyidentifygroupsbasedonlyonthegroupname,sotheywilltrytomergethegroups,which,canpossiblyhavedi erentpolicies.Again,thereisnoguaranteethatareconciliationispossible.Incaseareconciliationisnotpossible,theserverscandecidetodestroythegroupandinformallclientsthatthegroupwasdestroyedbecauseapolicyreconciliationwasnotpossible.IftheGCSidenti- esgroupsnotonlybyname2,thengroupscreatedindependentlyinpartitionedcomponentswillbein-terpretedasdi erentgroupsandnomergeandpolicyreconciliationwillberequired.
Fromthepreviousscenariositisapparentthatthepolicyframeworkshouldspecifyandprovidesupportfortheselectionofanewgroupcontroller.Thereareseveraleventsthatcandrivesuchaneed:
aclientorservercrashed:Theclientthatcrashedwasthegroupcontroller,ortheserverthatcrashedwasservingthegroupcontroller3.
anetworkpartitionoccurred:Thegroupcon-trollerwillenduponlyinonenetworkcomponent,whiletheothercomponentswillneedtoselectanewgroupcontroller.
anetworkmergeoccurredandpolicyreconcili-ationwaspossible:Inthiscasethenewmerge
2One
possibilityistoaddalsotheidenti eroftheserver
thatrepresentstheentirecon gurationofserversinanetworkcomponent.
3Ourfailuremodelassumesthatclientsarenotredirectedwhentheservertheyareconnectedtocrashes,soalltheclientsconnectedtothatserverwillfailtoo.
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说教育文库A Framework for Role-Based Access Control in Group Communica(6)在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: